2023 (5)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Aria Fischer | Player of the Year • First Team |
| Ryann Neushul | First Team |
| Maya Avital | First Team |
| Jenna Flynn | Second Team |
| Jewel Roemer | Second Team |
2022 (5)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Makenzie Fischer | Player of the Year • First Team |
| Aria Fischer | First Team |
| Maya Avital | Second Team |
| Ryann Neushul | Second Team |
| Jewel Roemer | Honorable Mention |
2021 (5)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Sarah Klass | First Team |
| Jewel Roemer | First Team |
| Emalia Eichelberger | Second Team |
| Chloe Harbilas | Third Team |
| Hannah Constandse | Honorable Mention |
2020 (4)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Emalia Eichelberger | First Team |
| Sarah Klass | First Team |
| Hannah Shabb | Second Team |
| Hannah Constandse | Honorable Mention |
2019 (6)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Makenzie Fischer | Player of the Year • First Team |
| Aria Fischer | First Team |
| Emalia Eichelberger | Second Team |
| Kat Klass | Second Team |
| Ryann Neushul | Third Team |
| Sarah Klass | Honorable Mention |
2018 (6)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Makenzie Fischer | First Team |
| Jordan Raney | First Team |
| Aria Fischer | Second Team |
| Julia Hermann | Third Team |
| Kat Klass | Third Team |
| Katie Dudley | Honorable Mention |
2017 (6)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Maggie Steffens | Player of the Year • First Team |
| Jamie Neushul | First Team |
| Makenzie Fischer | Second Team |
| Gabby Stone | Second Team |
| Dani Jackovich | Honorable Mention |
| Jordan Raney | Honorable Mention |
2016 (7)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Jamie Neushul | First Team |
| Kat Klass | Second Team |
| Jordan Raney | Second Team |
| Julia Hermann | Third Team |
| Dani Jackovich | Third Team |
| Gurpreet Sohi | Honorable Mention |
| Anna Yelizarova | Honorable Mention |
2015 (6)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Maggie Steffens | Player of the Year • First Team |
| Kiley Neushul | First Team |
| Ashley Grossman | First Team |
| Gabby Stone | Third Team |
| Jamie Neushul | Honorable Mention |
| Jordan Raney | Honorable Mention |
2014 (7)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Annika Dries | Player of the Year • First Team |
| Kiley Neushul | First Team |
| Maggie Steffens | First Team |
| Kaley Dodson | Third Team |
| Ashley Grossman | Honorable Mention |
| Jamie Neushul | Honorable Mention |
| Gabby Stone | Honorable Mention |
2013 (6)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Melissa Seidemann | Player of the Year • First Team |
| Maggie Steffens | First Team |
| Annika Dries | Second Team |
| Kiley Neushul | Second Team |
| Kate Baldoni | Honorable Mention |
| Kaley Dodson | Honorable Mention |
2012 (8)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Kiley Neushul | Player of the Year • First Team |
| Kaley Dodson | First Team |
| Alyssa Lo | Second Team |
| Kate Baldoni | Third Team |
| Cassie Churnside | Honorable Mention |
| Monica Coughlan | Honorable Mention |
| Ashley Grossman | Honorable Mention |
| Pallavi Menon | Honorable Mention |
2011 (6)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Annika Dries | Player of the Year • First Team |
| Amber Oland | First Team |
| Melissa Seidemann | First Team |
| Alyssa Lo | Second Team |
| Kaley Dodson | Honorable Mention |
| Kim Krueger | Honorable Mention |
2010 (5)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Kelly Eaton | First Team |
| Jessica Steffens | First Team |
| Amber Oland | Second Team |
| Melissa Seidemann | Second Team |
| Annika Dries | Third Team |
2009 (4)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Lauren Silver | First Team |
| Jessica Steffens | First Team |
| Melissa Seidemann | Third Team |
| Kelly Eaton | Honorable Mention |
2008 (4)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Lauren Silver | First Team |
| Jacquelyn Gauthier | Second Team |
| Amber Oland | Third Team |
| Kelly Eaton | Honorable Mention |
2007 (5)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Katie Hansen | First Team |
| Christina Hewko | First Team |
| Alison Gregorka | Second Team |
| Meridith McColl | Second Team |
| Lauren Silver | Third Team |
2006 (5)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Katie Hansen | First Team |
| Christina Hewko | Second Team |
| Scotti Shafer | Second Team |
| Meridith McColl | Second Team |
| Lauren Silver | Honorable Mention |
2005 (4)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Christina Hewko | First Team |
| Katie Hansen | Second Team |
| Hannah Luber | Second Team |
| Meridith McColl | Second Team |
2004 (3)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Wendy Watkins | First Team |
| Hannah Luber | Second Team |
| Christina Hewko | Honorable Mention |
2003 (4)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Jackie Frank | Player of the Year • First Team |
| Julie Gardner | First Team |
| Brenda Villa | First Team |
| Wendy Watkins | Third Team |
2002 (5)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Jackie Frank | Player of the Year • First Team |
| Ellen Estes | First Team |
| Brenda Villa | First Team |
| Margie Dingeldein | Third Team |
| Kate Pettit | Honorable Mention |
2001 (6)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Brenda Villa | Player of the Year • First Team |
| Jackie Frank | First Team |
| Margie Dingeldein | Second Team |
| Ellen Estes | Second Team |
| Julie Gardner | Honorable Mention |
| Anne-Marie Keenan | Honorable Mention |
2000 (6)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Margie Dingeldein | First Team |
| Jackie Frank | Second Team |
| Julie Gardner | Third Team |
| Kris Koblik | Third Team |
| Anne-Marie Keenan | Honorable Mention |
| Kelly Shouey | Honorable Mention |
1999 (5)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Margie Dingeldein | First Team |
| Kelly Shouey | First Team |
| Heather Crary | Second Team |
| Kris Koblik | Second Team |
| Anne-Marie Keenan | Honorable Mention |
1998 (4)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Ellen Estes | First Team |
| Suze Gardner | First Team |
| Heather Crary | Third Team |
| Kris Koblik | Honorable Mention |
1997 (4)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Suze Gardner | First Team |
| Ellen Estes | Second Team |
| Alice Cathcart | Honorable Mention |
| Heather Crary | Honorable Mention |
1996 (3)
| Player | Team |
|---|---|
| Lindsay Welsh | Second Team |
| Heather Crary | Third Team |
| Lindsay Tam | Honorable Mention |