| Season | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|
| 2022 • 2023 | Joshua Karty | Placekicker |
| 2017 | Bryce Love | Running Back |
| 2015 | Joshua Garnett | Offensive Guard |
| 2015 | Christian McCaffrey | Running Back All-Purpose Kick Returner |
| 2014 | Andrus Peat | Offensive Tackle |
| 2013 | Ty Montgomery | Kick Returner All-Purpose |
| 2013 | Trent Murphy | Outside Linebacker |
| 2012 • 2013 | David Yankey | Offensive Tackle/Guard • Offensive Guard |
| 2012 | Zach Ertz | Tight End |
| 2011 | David DeCastro | Offensive Guard |
| 2011 | Coby Fleener | Tight End |
| 2011 | Andrew Luck | Quarterback |
| 2011 | Jonathan Martin | Offensive Tackle |
| 2011 | Chase Thomas | Outside Linebacker |
| 2010 | Chase Beeler | Center |
| 2010 | Owen Marecic | All-Purpose |
| 2009 | Toby Gerhart | Running Back |
| 2001 | Eric Heitmann | Offensive Guard |
| 2001 | Luke Powell | Kick Returner |
| 2001 | Tank Williams | Free Safety |
| 1999 | Troy Walters | Flanker |
| 1997 | Kailee Wong | Defensive End |
| 1992 | Ron George | Outside Linebacker |
| 1992 | Glyn Milburn | Running Back |
| 1990 • 1991 | Bob Whitfield | Offensive Tackle |
| 1990 | Ed McCaffrey | Wide Receiver |
| 1986 | Brad Muster | Fullback |
| 1986 | Dave Wyman | Inside Linebacker |
| 1981 | Darrin Nelson | Halfback |
| 1980 • 1982 | John Elway | Quarterback |
| 1979 • 1980 | Ken Margerum | Flanker |
| 1977 | Guy Benjamin | Quarterback |
| 1977 | Gordon King | Offensive Tackle |
| 1976 | Duncan McColl | Defensive End |
| 1973 • 1974 | Pat Donovan | Defensive End |
| 1973 | Mike Boryla | Quarterback |
| 1973 | Rod Garcia | Placekicker |
| 1973 | Roger Stillwell | Defensive End |
| 1971 | Pete Lazetich | Defensive Tackle |
| 1971 | Jeff Siemon | Linebacker |
| 1970 | Jim Plunkett | Quarterback |
| 1969 | Don Parish | Linebacker |
| 1968 | Malcolm Snider | Offensive Tackle |
| 1964 | Jack Chapple | Offensive Guard |
| 1964 | Ray Handley | Halfback |
| 1962 | Edward A. Cummings | Fullback |
| 1959 | Chris Burford | Tight End |
| 1956 | John Brodie | Quarterback |
| 1955 • 1956 | Paul Wiggin | Defensive Tackle |
| 1953 | Bob Garrett | Quarterback |
| 1953 | Sam Morley | End |
| 1951 | Gary Kerkorian | Quarterback Defensive Back |
| 1950 | Bill McColl | End |
| 1949 | Ken Rose | End |
| 1942 | Chuck Taylor | Offensive Guard |
| 1940 • 1941 | Frankie Albert | Quarterback |
| 1940 | Hugh Gallarneau | Halfback |
| 1934 • 1935 | Bobby Grayson | Fullback |
| 1934 • 1935 | Monk Moscrip | End |
| 1934 | Bones Hamilton | Tackle |
| 1934 | Bob Reynolds | Offensive Tackle |
| 1932 • 1933 | Bill Corbus | Offensive Guard |
| 1930 | Phil Moffatt | Halfback |
| 1928 | Seraphim Post | Offensive Guard |
| 1928 | Don Robesky | Offensive Guard |
| 1926 | Ted Shipkey | End |
| 1925 | Ernie Nevers | Fullback |
| 1924 | Jim Lawson | End |
First Team All-America
Share