World Series
| Player | Team | Year |
|---|---|---|
| Tillie Shafer | New York Giants | 1912 |
| Tillie Shafer | New York Giants | 1913 |
| Bobby Brown | New York Yankees | 1947 |
| Bobby Brown | New York Yankees | 1949 |
| Bobby Brown | New York Yankees | 1950 |
| Bobby Brown | New York Yankees | 1951 |
| Chuck Essegian | Los Angeles Dodgers | 1959 |
| Jim Lonborg | Boston Red Sox | 1967 |
| Bob Boone | Philadelphia Phillies | 1980 |
| Ed Sprague | Toronto Blue Jays | 1992 |
| Ed Sprague | Toronto Blue Jays | 1993 |
| Ruben Amaro Jr. | Cleveland | 1995 |
| Mike Aldrete | New York Yankees | 1996 |
| Mike Mussina | New York Yankees | 2001 |
| Mike Mussina | New York Yankees | 2003 |
| Eric Bruntlett | Houston Astros | 2005 |
| Eric Bruntlett | Philadelphia Phillies | 2008 |
| Eric Bruntlett | Philadelphia Phillies | 2009 |
| Jeremy Guthrie | Kansas City Royals | 2014 |
| Jason Castro | Houston Astros | 2021 |
| Mark Appel | Philadelphia Phillies | 2022 |
| Jason Castro | Houston Astros | 2022 |
League Championship Series
| Player | Team | Round | Year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Frank Duffy | San Francisco Giants | NLCS | 1971 |
| Bob Boone | Philadelphia Phillies | NLCS | 1976 |
| Jim Lonborg | Philadelphia Phillies | NLCS | 1976 |
| Bob Boone | Philadelphia Phillies | NLCS | 1977 |
| Jim Lonborg | Philadelphia Phillies | NLCS | 1977 |
| Dave Frost | Anaheim Angels | ALCS | 1979 |
| Bob Boone | Philadelphia Phillies | NLCS | 1980 |
| Bob Boone | Anaheim Angels | ALCS | 1982 |
| Mike Aldrete | San Francisco Giants | NLCS | 1987 |
| Bob Boone | Anaheim Angels | ALCS | 1988 |
| Steve Buechele | Pittsburgh Pirates | NLCS | 1991 |
| Ed Sprague | Toronto Blue Jays | ALCS | 1992 |
| Ed Sprague | Toronto Blue Jays | ALCS | 1993 |
| Jack McDowell | Chicago White Sox | ALCS | 1993 |
| Ruben Amaro Jr. | Cleveland | ALCS | 1995 |
| Mike Mussina | Baltimore Orioles | ALCS | 1996 |
| Mike Aldrete | New York Yankees | ALCS | 1996 |
| Mike Mussina | Baltimore Orioles | ALCS | 1997 |
| Jeffrey Hammonds | Cleveland | ALCS | 1997 |
| Mike Mussina | New York Yankees | ALCS | 2001 |
| Mike Mussina | New York Yankees | ALCS | 2002 |
| Rick Helling | Florida Marlins | NLCS | 2003 |
| David McCarty | Boston Red Sox | ALCS | 2003 |
| Mike Mussina | New York Yankees | ALCS | 2003 |
| Eric Bruntlett | Houston Astros | NLCS | 2004 |
| Mike Mussina | New York Yankees | ALCS | 2004 |
| Eric Bruntlett | Houston Astros | NLCS | 2005 |
| Ryan Garko | Cleveland | ALCS | 2007 |
| Eric Bruntlett | Philadelphia Phillies | NLCS | 2008 |
| Eric Bruntlett | Philadelphia Phillies | NLCS | 2009 |
| Jeremy Guthrie | Kansas City Royals | ALCS | 2014 |
| Tommy Edman | St. Louis Cardinals | NLCS | 2019 |
| Jason Castro | Houston Astros | ALCS | 2021 |
| Mark Appel | Philadelphia Phillies | NLCS | 2022 |
| Jason Castro | Houston Astros | ALCS | 2022 |
Division Series
| Player | Team | Round | Year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bob Boone | Anaheim Angels | ALDS | 1981 |
| Jack McDowell | New York Yankees | ALDS | 1995 |
| Jack McDowell | Cleveland | ALDS | 1996 |
| Brian Johnson | San Diego Padres | NLDS | 1996 |
| Mike Mussina | Baltimore Orioles | ALDS | 1997 |
| Brian Johnson | San Diego Padres | NLDS | 1997 |
| Jeffrey Hammonds | Cleveland | ALDS | 1997 |
| Rick Helling | Texas Rangers | ALDS | 1998 |
| Rick Helling | Texas Rangers | ALDS | 1999 |
| Ed Sprague | Seattle Mariners | ALDS | 2001 |
| Mike Mussina | New York Yankees | ALDS | 2001 |
| Mike Mussina | New York Yankees | ALDS | 2002 |
| Rick Helling | Florida Marlins | NLDS | 2002 |
| Rick Helling | Florida Marlins | NLDS | 2003 |
| Jeffrey Hammonds | Florida Marlins | NLDS | 2003 |
| Mike Mussina | New York Yankees | ALDS | 2003 |
| Eric Bruntlett | Houston Astros | NLDS | 2004 |
| Mike Mussina | New York Yankees | ALDS | 2004 |
| Eric Bruntlett | Houston Astros | NLDS | 2005 |
| John Gall | St. Louis Cardinals | NLDS | 2005 |
| Mike Mussina | New York Yankees | ALDS | 2005 |
| Mike Mussina | New York Yankees | ALDS | 2006 |
| Ryan Garko | New York Yankees | ALDS | 2007 |
| Mike Mussina | New York Yankees | ALDS | 2007 |
| Eric Bruntlett | Philadelphia Phillies | NLDS | 2008 |
| Jed Lowrie | Boston Red Sox | ALDS | 2009 |
| Sam Fuld | Tampa Bay Rays | ALDS | 2011 |
| John Mayberry Jr. | Philadelphia Phillies | NLDS | 2011 |
| Drew Storen | Washington Nationals | NLDS | 2012 |
| Jed Lowrie | Oakland Athletics | ALDS | 2013 |
| Sam Fuld | Tampa Bay Rays | ALDS | 2013 |
| Drew Storen | Washington Nationals | NLDS | 2014 |
| Jeremy Guthrie | Kansas City Royals | ALDS | 2014 |
| Jason Castro | Houston Astros | ALDS | 2015 |
| Stephen Piscotty | Oakland Athletics | NLDS | 2015 |
| Jed Lowrie | Houston Astros | ALDS | 2015 |
| Tommy Edman | St. Louis Cardinals | NLDS | 2019 |
| Jason Castro | San Diego Padres | NLDS | 2020 |
| Stephen Piscotty | Oakland Athletics | ALDS | 2020 |
| Jason Castro | Houston Astros | ALDS | 2021 |
| Austin Slater | San Francisco Giants | NLDS | 2021 |
| Mark Appel | Philadelphia Phillies | NLDS | 2022 |
| Jason Castro | Houston Astros | ALDS | 2022 |
| Cal Quantrill | Cleveland Guardians | ALDS | 2022 |
| Kyle Stowers | Baltimore Orioles | ALDS | 2023 |
Wild Card
| Player | Team | Round | Year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sam Fuld | Oakland Athletics | ALWC | 2014 |
| Jed Lowrie | Oakland Athletics | ALWC | 2014 |
| Jeremy Guthrie | Kansas City Royals | ALWC | 2014 |
| Jed Lowrie | Houston Astros | ALWC | 2015 |
| Jason Castro | Minnesota Twins | ALWC | 2017 |
| Stephen Piscotty | Oakland Athletics | ALWC | 2018 |
| Jed Lowrie | Oakland Athletics | ALWC | 2018 |
| Alex Blandino | Cincinnati Reds | NLWC | 2020 |
| Jason Castro | San Diego Padres | NLWC | 2020 |
| Tommy Edman | St. Louis Cardinals | NLWC | 2020 |
| Nico Hoerner | Chicago Cubs | NLWC | 2020 |
| Stephen Piscotty | Oakland Athletics | ALWC | 2020 |
| Cal Quantrill | Cleveland Indians | ALWC | 2020 |
| Tommy Edman | St. Louis Cardinals | NLWC | 2021 |
| Mark Appel | Philadelphia Phillies | NLWC | 2022 |
| Tommy Edman | St. Louis Cardinals | NLWC | 2022 |
| Cal Quantrill | Cleveland Guardians | ALWC | 2022 |