| Year | Name (Event) |
|---|---|
| 1964 | Al Miyamoto (PH) |
| 1970 | Steve Rochell (SR) |
| 1972 | Howard Bessen (SR) Steve Hug (AA, PH, PB, HB) |
| 1973 | Steve Hug (AA, V, PB, HB) Ted Marcy (PH) |
| 1974 | Howard Bessen (SR) Steve Hug (AA, PB, HB) Ted Marcy (PH) |
| 1975 | Ted Marcy (PH) |
| 1976 | Ted Marcy (PH) |
| 1984 | Jon Louis (SR) |
| 1985 | Jon Louis (AA, PB) |
| 1986 | Randy Besosa (HB) Jon Louis (AA, HB) |
| 1988 | Randy Besosa (AA, PB) Mike Matzek (SR) Conrad Voorsanger (PB) |
| 1989 | Tim Ryan (AA, PB) Scott Schaeffer (PB) Conrad Voorsanger (AA, PB) |
| 1990 | Jair Lynch (HB) Conrad Voorsanger (PB) Charles Loop (HB) |
| 1991 | Jair Lynch (AA, PB, HB) |
| 1992 | Jair Lynch *** (AA, FX, PH, PB, HB) Tim Ryan (AA, PH, SR) |
| 1993 | Jair Lynch (FX, PB) Josh Stein (FX) Jing Wei Liang (PH) |
| 1994 | Ian Bachrach (FX) Mark Booth (AA, FX, PH) Josh Stein (AA, PH, V) Keith Wiley (V) |
| 1995 | Ian Bachrach (V) Jamie Ellis (PB) Andrew Manson (SR) Josh Stein (AA, FX, PH, SR) Keith Wiley (V) |
| 1996 | Ian Bachrach (FX, V, HB) Jamie Ellis (PB) Jeremy Herman (PH) Clarence Miao (V) Keith Wiley (AA) |
| 1997 | Scott Finkelstein (PH) |
| 1999 | Jason Katsampes (AA, PH, PB) |
| 2001 | Marshall Erwin (SR) Dan Gill (V) |
| 2002 | David Durante (HB) Marshall Erwin (SR) Dan Gill (V) |
| 2003 | Marshall Erwin (SR) Dan Gill (AA, V) |
| 2004 | Peter Derman (SR) Dan Gill *** (AA, FX, PH, V, HB) |
| 2006 | Dylan Carney (V, HB) Peter Derman (SR) Nate Downs (HB) Sho Nakamori (AA, FX) Alex Schorsch (SR) David Sender (AA, SR, V, PB) |
| 2007 | Dylan Carney (HB) Peter Derman (SR) Chris Harper (PH) Alex Schorsch (SR) David Sender (AA, SR, V) |
| 2008 | Alex Buscaglia (HB) Dylan Carney (HB) Josh Dixon (FX, V, HB) Bryant Hadden (SR) Sho Nakamori (AA, PH, PB) Kyle Oi (PH) David Sender (AA, SR, V) Greg Ter-Zakhariants (FX, PH) |
| 2009 | Alex Buscaglia (HB) Tim Gentry (V, SR) Bryant Hadden (SR) Ryan Lieberman (PB) Sho Nakamori (PB, HB, FX) Nicholas Noone (SR, PB) Kyle Oi (SR) |
| 2010 | Alex Buscaglia (FX, HB) Josh Dixon (V, PB, HB) Tim Gentry (SR, V) Ryan Lieberman (PB) John Martin (PH) Nicholas Noone (PB, SR) Eddie Penev (V, FX) Abhinav Ramani (HB) |
| 2011 | Alex Buscaglia (HB, PB) Josh Dixon (FX, AA) Cameron Foreman (PB) Tim Gentry (SR, V, FX) Ryan Lieberman (AA) Eddie Penev (FX) Chris Turner (PH) |
| 2012 | Eddie Penev (AA, FX, V) Sean Senters (FX) Cameron Foreman (PB) Paul Hichwa (FX) |
| 2013 | Cameron Foreman (HB) Brian Knott (PB) John Martin (PH) Eddie Penev (AA, FX, V) Sean Senters (FX, V) Dennis Zaremski (PB) |
| 2014 | Brian Knott (PB) Michael Levy (FX) Akash Modi (AA, PH, PB) Sean Senters (FX, V) Dennis Zaremski (SR) |
| 2015 | Brian Knott (PH, PB) Akash Modi ** / *** (AA, FX, PH, PB, HB) Robert Neff (HB) Taylor Seaton (V) Sean Senters (V) |
| 2016 | Brian Knott (PB) Akash Modi ** (AA, FX, PB, HB) Taylor Seaton (HB) Dennis Zaremski (SR, PB) |
| 2017 | Akash Modi ** / *** (AA, PH, V, PB, HB) Andrew Misiolek (PH) Robert Neff (AA, PB, HB) |
| 2018 | Grant Breckenridge (HB) Robert Neff (AA, HB) Blake Sun (PB) |
| 2019 | Jacob Barrus (PB) Andrew Bitner (SR) Grant Breckenridge (HB, AA) Ian Gunther (SR) David Jessen (HB) Brody Malone *** (PB, HB, FX, SR, AA) Bailey Perez (FX) Bryan Perla (FX, VT) Blake Sun (PB) |
| 2020 * | Brandon Briones (VT, AA) Trevor DiGerolamo (SR) Ian Gunther (PH, SR, PB, AA) Connor Lewis (VT) Riley Loos (SR, AA) Brody Malone (VT, PB, AA) Zach Martin (VT) Curran Phillips (VT, PB) |
* Denotes team’s highest number of All-Americans in one season (16 awards)
** Akash Modi holds school career record of 17 All-American awards
*** Jair Lynch ('92), Dan Gill ('04), Akash Modi ('15 & '17) and Brody Malone ('19) are tied for most All-America honors at a single NCAA Championships (5)