| Season | Individual | All-America Team |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 (5) | Paula Martin Sampedro Megha Ganne Kelly Xu Rachel Heck Sadie Englemann | First Team (WGCA, Golfweek) First Team (WGCA), Second Team (Golfweek) Second Team (WGCA, Golfweek) Third Team (Golfweek), Honorable Mention (WGCA) Honorable Mention (WGCA, Golfweek) |
| 2023 (3) | Rose Zhang Sadie Englemann Megha Ganne | First Team (WGCA, Golfweek) Second Team (WGCA, Golfweek) Honorable Mention (WGCA, Golfweek) |
| 2022 (4) | Rose Zhang Brooke Seay Aline Krauter Rachel Heck | First Team (WGCA, Golfweek) First Team (Golfweek), Second Team (WGCA) Second Team (WGCA, Golfweek) Third Team (Golfweek) |
| 2021 (2) | Rachel Heck Angelina Ye | First Team (WGCA, Golfweek) First Team (WGCA), Third Team (Golfweek) |
| 2020 (2) | Angelina Ye Aline Krauter | First Team (Golfweek), Second Team (WGCA) Second Team (WGCA, Golfweek) |
| 2019 (3) | Andrea Lee Albane Valenzuela Aline Krauter | First Team (WGCA, Golfweek) First Team (WGCA, Golfweek) Honorable Mention (WGCA, Golfweek) |
| 2018 (2) | Andrea Lee Albane Valenzuela | First Team (WGCA) Honorable Mention (WGCA) |
| 2017 (3) | Andrea Lee Casey Danielson Albane Valenzuela | First Team (WGCA) Second Team (WGCA) Second Team (WGCA) |
| 2016 (2) | Lauren Kim Mariah Stackhouse | First Team (WGCA, Golfweek) Second Team (WGCA), Third Team (Golfweek) |
| 2015 (2) | Lauren Kim Mariah Stackhouse | First Team (WGCA, Golfweek) Second Team (WGCA), Third Team (Golfweek) |
| 2014 (3) | Lauren Kim Mariah Stackhouse Casey Danielson | First Team (WGCA), Second Team (Golfweek) First Team (WGCA, Golfweek) Honorable Mention (Golfweek) |
| 2013 (1) | Mariah Stackhouse | First Team (WGCA, Golfweek) |
| 2012 (1) | Sally Watson | Honorable Mention (WGCA) |
| 2010 (1) | Sally Watson | Honorable Mention (WGCA) |
| 2008 (1) | Mari Chun | Honorable Mention (WGCA) |
| 2007 (3) | Mari Chun Lauren Todd Jennifer Tangtiphaiboontana | Second Team (WGCA, Golfweek) Third Team (Golfweek), Honorable Mention (WGCA) Honorable Mention (Golfweek) |
| 2002 (1) | Marcia Wallis | Honorable Mention (WGCA) |
| 2001 (2) | Stephanie Keever Hilary Homeyer | First Team (WGCA) Second Team (WGCA) |
| 2000 (2) | Stephanie Keever Hilary Homeyer | Second Team (WGCA) Second Team (WGCA) |
| 1999 (2) | Stephanie Keever Hilary Homeyer | Second Team (WGCA) Honorable Mention (WGCA) |
| 1998 (2) | Stephanie Keever Hilary Homeyer | Second Team (WGCA) Honorable Mention (WGCA) |
| 1997 (2) | Andrea Baxter Mhairi McKay | First Team (WGCA) First Team (WGCA) |
| 1996 (1) | Mhairi McKay | First Team (WGCA) |
| 1995 (2) | Andrea Baxter Mhairi McKay | Second Team (WGCA) Second Team (WGCA) |
| 1994 (1) | Mhairi McKay | First Team (WGCA) |
| 1993 (1) | Martha Richards | Honorable Mention (WGCA) |
| 1992 (2) | Audrey Wooding Adele Moore | Second Team (WGCA) Second Team (WGCA) |
| 1991 (2) | Adele Moore Audrey Wooding | Second Team (WGCA) Honorable Mention (WGCA) |
| 1989 (1) | Adele Moore | Honorable Mention (WGCA) |
| 1988 (2) | Kay Cornelius Jodi Figley | Second Team (WGCA) Honorable Mention (WGCA) |
| 1987 (1) | Kathleen McCarthy | First Team (WGCA) |
| 1984 (1) | Kathleen McCarthy | First Team (WGCA) |
| 1983 (2) | Kathleen McCarthy Joanne Pacillo | First Team (WGCA) Second Team (WGCA) |
| 1979 (1) | Sally Voss | First Team (WGCA) |
| 1978 (1) | Sally Voss | First Team (WGCA) |
| 1975 (1) | Pat Cornett | First Team (WGCA) |
| 1971 (1) | Shelley Hamlin | First Team (WGCA) |
| 1970 (1) | Shelley Hamlin | First Team (WGCA) |
| 1969 (1) | Shelley Hamlin | First Team (WGCA) |