| Name | W | L | Pct. |
| Wolters, Ryan | 90 | 16 | .849 |
| Abrams, Geoff | 88 | 10 | .898 |
| O'Brien, Alex | 89 | 27 | .767 |
| Warburg, Sam | 88 | 11 | .889 |
| Goldstein, Paul | 84 | 16 | .840 |
| Salzenstein, Jeff | 81 | 23 | .779 |
| Kim, Alex | 78 | 12 | .867 |
| Martin, David | 77 | 23 | .770 |
| Grabb, Jim | 72 | 15 | .827 |
| Corkery, KC | 71 | 18 | .798 |
| Klahn, Bradley | 70 | 22 | .761 |
| McEnroe, Patrick | 67 | 22 | .753 |
| Thacher, Ryan | 66 | 30 | .688 |
| Thomas, Jim | 64 | 11 | .853 |
| Clayton, Alex | 64 | 26 | .711 |
| Wan, James | 60 | 11 | .845 |
| Elliott, Grant | 60 | 11 | .845 |
| Hippensteel, K.J. | 60 | 15 | .800 |
| Ansari, Ali | 59 | 14 | .808 |
| Becker, Ricky | 57 | 8 | .877 |
| Scott, Scotty | 57 | 17 | .770 |
| Morrissey, John | 57 | 26 | .687 |
| Rennert, Peter | 56 | 14 | .800 |
| Hirshman, Greg | 56 | 18 | .756 |
| Bryan, Bob | 55 | 3 | .948 |
| Pade, James | 54 | 15 | .782 |
| Fawcett, Tom | 53 | 23 | .697 |
| Mayotte, Tim | 52 | 11 | .825 |
| Davis, Scott | 50 | 8 | .862 |
| Groslimond, Gery | 48 | 15 | .762 |
| Wilczynski, David | 48 | 31 | .608 |
| Maze, Bill | 46 | 15 | .754 |
| Geller, Axel | 46 | 30 | .605 |
| Delaney, Jim | 44 | 8 | .846 |
| Stineman, Robert | 44 | 30 | .595 |
| Tanner, Roscoe | 43 | 6 | .878 |
| Palmer, Jared | 42 | 11 | .792 |
| Fery, Arthur | 41 | 12 | .774 |
| Bryan, Mike | 40 | 4 | .909 |
| Dupre, Pat | 40 | 8 | .833 |
| Whitlinger, John | 40 | 9 | .816 |
| Wright, Perry | 40 | 11 | .784 |
| Basing, Max | 40 | 15 | .727 |
* Bold are active players