| 1957 (1) |
| Jon Douglas (Second Team) |
| 1958 (3) |
| Jon Douglas |
| Dave Nelson (Second Team) |
| Brooks Rawlins (Second Team) |
| 1959 (2) |
| Dave Nelson (Second Team) |
| Dick Ogden (Third Team) |
| 1960 (1) |
| Jim Jeffries (Second Team) |
| 1962 (2) |
| Yoshi Minegishi (Second Team) |
| Dick Ogden |
| 1965 (1) |
| James Beste |
| 1966 (1) |
| James Beste |
| 1969 (1) |
| Paul Gerken |
| 1970 (1) |
| Roscoe Tanner |
| 1971 (2) |
| Alex Mayer |
| Roscoe Tanner |
| 1972 (4) |
| Jim Delaney |
| Chico Hagey |
| Alex Mayer |
| Roscoe Tanner |
| 1973 (3) |
| Jim Delaney |
| Rick Fisher |
| Alex Mayer |
| 1974 (4) |
| Jim Delaney |
| Chico Hagey |
| Nick Saviano |
| John Whitlinger |
| 1975 (3) |
| Jim Delaney |
| Nick Saviano |
| John Whitlinger |
| 1976 (4) |
| Pat DuPre |
| Bill Maze |
| Matt Mitchell |
| Mark Mitchell |
| 1977 (3) |
| Bill Maze |
| Matt Mitchell |
| Perry Wright |
| 1978 (4) |
| Bill Maze |
| John McEnroe |
| Matt Mitchell |
| Perry Wright |
| 1979 (2) |
| Lloyd Bourne |
| Peter Rennert |
| 1980 (3) |
| Peter Rennert |
| Lloyd Bourne |
| Tim Mayotte |
| 1981 (4) |
| Scott Bondurant |
| Scott Davis |
| Jim Gurfein |
| Tim Mayotte |
| 1982 (2) |
| Scott Davis |
| Jeff Arons |
| 1983 (1) |
| Scott Davis |
| 1984 (3) |
| Dan Goldie |
| Jim Grabb |
| John Letts |
| 1985 (4) |
| Dan Goldie |
| Jim Grabb |
| John Letts |
| Derrick Rostagno |
| 1986 (3) |
| Patrick McEnroe |
| Dan Goldie |
| Jim Grabb |
| 1987 (2) |
| Patrick McEnroe |
| Jeff Tarango |
| 1988 (3) |
| Patrick McEnroe |
| Jeff Tarango |
| David Wheaton |
| 1989 (2) |
| Jeff Tarango |
| Alex O'Brien |
| 1990 (4) |
| Jared Palmer |
| Alex O'Brien |
| Jonathan Stark |
| Jason Yee |
| 1991 (4) |
| Jared Palmer |
| Alex O'Brien |
| Jonathan Stark |
| Jason Yee |
| 1992 (4) |
| Chris Cocotos |
| Alex O'Brien |
| Vimal Patel |
| Jason Yee |
| 1993 (3) |
| Chris Cocotos |
| Mike Flanagan |
| Vimal Patel |
| 1994 (2) |
| Chris Cocotos |
| Mike Flanagan |
| 1995 (3) |
| Paul Goldstein |
| Scott Humphries |
| Jeff Salzenstein |
| 1996 (4) |
| Paul Goldstein |
| Jeff Salzenstein |
| Jim Thomas |
| Ryan Wolters |
| 1997 (4) |
| Bob Bryan |
| Mike Bryan |
| Paul Goldstein |
| Ryan Wolters |
| 1998 (4) |
| Bob Bryan |
| Mike Bryan |
| Paul Goldstein |
| Ryan Wolters |
| 1999 (2) |
| K.J. Hippensteel |
| Ryan Wolters |
| 2000 (3) |
| Geoff Abrams |
| K.J. Hippensteel |
| Alex Kim |
| 2001 (4) |
| K.J. Hippensteel |
| Alex Kim |
| Scott Lipsky |
| David Martin |
| 2002 (4) |
| Ryan Haviland |
| K.J. Hippensteel |
| Scott Lipsky |
| David Martin |
| 2003 (3) |
| KC Corkery |
| Scott Lipsky |
| David Martin |
| 2004 (2) |
| KC Corkery |
| Sam Warburg |
| 2005 (2) |
| KC Corkery |
| Sam Warburg |
| 2006 (2) |
| Matt Bruch |
| KC Corkery |
| 2008 (1) |
| Alex Clayton |
| 2009 (1) |
| Alex Clayton |
| 2010 (2) |
| Bradley Klahn |
| Ryan Thacher |
| 2011 (2) |
| Bradley Klahn |
| Ryan Thacher |
| 2012 (2) |
| Bradley Klahn |
| Ryan Thacher |
| 2015 (2) |
| John Morrissey |
| Robert Stineman |
| 2016 (1) |
| Tom Fawcett |
| 2017 (1) |
| Tom Fawcett |
| 2018 (1) |
| Tom Fawcett |
| 2019 (1) |
| Axel Geller |
| 2020 (1) |
| Alexandre Rotsaert |
| 2022 (1) |
| Arthur Fery |
| 2023 (2) |
| Arthur Fery |
| Nishesh Basavareddy |
| 2024 (1) |
| Nishesh Basavareddy |