| Rank | Name | Record |
| 1. | Julie Scott (1997) | 29-1 |
| 2. | Gabriela Lastra (2000) | 28-4 |
| 3. | Nicole Gibbs (2011) | 27-0 |
| Debbie Graham (1989) | 27-0 | |
| Lauren Kalvaria (2001) | 27-0 | |
| Theresa Logar (2004) | 27-0 | |
| Heather Willens (1990) | 27-0 | |
| Keiko Tokuda (2002) | 27-1 | |
| 8. | Teri Whitlinger (1990) | 26-0 |
| Alice Barnes (2004) | 26-1 | |
| 10. | Alice Barnes (2003) | 25-0 |
| Debbie Graham (1990) | 25-0 | |
| Lauren Barnikow (2004) | 25-1 | |
| Erin Burdette (2002) | 25-1 | |
| Laura Granville (2001) | 25-1 | |
| Teri Whitlinger (1989) | 25-1 | |
| Heather Willens (1993) | 25-1 | |
| Anne Kremer (1997) | 25-2 | |
| Teri Whitlinger (1991) | 25-2 | |
| Sandra Birch (1988) | 25-3 | |
| Lisa Green (1990) | 25-3 | |
| Jennifer Heiser (1998) | 25-3 | |
| Teri Whitlinger (1988) | 25-3 | |
| Sandra DeSilva (1997) | 25-4 | |
| 24. | Gabriela Lastra (2001) | 24-1 |
| Mallory Burdette (2010) | 24-2 | |
| Lauren Barnikow (2001) | 24-2 | |
| Marissa Irvin (2000) | 24-2 | |
| Lisa Green (1989) | 24-3 | |
| Lauren Kalvaria (2000) | 24-3 | |
| Laxmi Poruri (1991) | 24-3 | |
| Jennifer Heiser (2000) | 24-5 | |
| Lauren Kalvaria (1999) | 24-5 |