| Batting Average (min. 300 at bats) |
| 1. | Jack Shepard (1951-53) | .362 |
| 2. | David McCarty (1989-91) | .359 |
| 3. | John Gall (1997-2000) | .358 |
| 4. | Mike Aldrete (1980-83) | .356 |
| 5. | Jeffrey Hammonds (1990-92) | .353 |
| 6. | Chris O’Riordan (1999-2002) | .352 |
| 7. | A.J. Hinch (1993-96) | .351 |
| Rick Lundblade (1982-85) | .351 |
| 9. | Ryan Garko (2000-03) | .350 |
| Carlos Quentin (2001-03) | .350 |
| | |
| Games Played |
| 1. | Paul Carey (1987-90) | 268 |
| 2. | Sam Fuld (2001-04) | 260 |
| 3. | John Gall (1997-2000) | 251 |
| 4. | Ruben Amaro, Jr. (1984-87) | 248 |
| 5. | Frank Carey (1986-89) | 247 |
| 6. | Tom Guardino (1975-78) | 246 |
| 7. | Mark Davis (1983-86) | 245 |
| 8. | Brian Hall (2001-04) | 243 |
| 9. | Edmund Muth (1997-2000) | 230 |
| 10. | A.J. Hinch (1993-96) | 229 |
| Darryl Stephens (1981-84) | 229 |
| | |
| At-Bats |
| 1. | Sam Fuld (2001-04) | 1,071 |
| 2. | John Gall (1997-2000) | 1,027 |
| 3. | Paul Carey (1987-90) | 983 |
| 4. | Larry Reynolds (1976-79) | 923 |
| 5. | Tom Guardino (1975-78) | 915 |
| 6. | Mark Davis (1983-86) | 901 |
| 7. | Frank Carey (1986-89) | 895 |
| 8. | Troy Paulsen (1987-90) | 880 |
| 9. | A.J. Hinch (1993-96) | 868 |
| 10. | Brian Dallimore (1993-96) | 858 |
| | |
| Runs |
| 1. | Sam Fuld (2001-04) | 268 |
| 2. | Mark Davis (1983-86) | 244 |
| 3. | Paul Carey (1987-90) | 233 |
| 4. | Edmund Muth (1997-2000) | 223 |
| 5. | Pete Stanicek (1982-85) | 220 |
| 6. | A.J. Hinch (1993-96) | 219 |
| 7. | John Gall (1997-2000) | 214 |
| 8. | Ruben Amaro, Jr. (1984-87) | 209 |
| 9. | Joe Kilburg (1995-97) | 208 |
| 10. | Mike Dotterer (1980-83) | 196 |
| | |
| Hits |
| 1. | John Gall (1997-2000) | 368 |
| 2. | Sam Fuld (2001-04) | 356 |
| 3. | Paul Carey (1987-90) | 331 |
| 4. | A.J. Hinch (1993-96) | 305 |
| 5. | Larry Reynolds (1976-79) | 300 |
| 6. | Troy Paulsen (1987-90) | 285 |
| 7. | Brian Dallimore (1993-96) | 279 |
| Mike Dotterer (1980-83) | 279 |
| 9. | Edmund Muth (1997-2000) | 275 |
| 10. | Mark Davis (1983-86) | 269 |
| | |
| Doubles |
| 1. | John Gall (1997-2000) | 80 |
| 2. | Troy Paulsen (1987-90) | 67 |
| 3. | Paul Carey (1987-90) | 66 |
| 4. | Edmund Muth (1997-2000) | 62 |
| 5. | Ryan Garko (2000-03) | 60 |
| 6. | Sam Fuld (2001-04) | 58 |
| A.J. Hinch (1993-96) | 58 |
| 8. | Josh Hochgesang (1996-99) | 56 |
| 9. | Brian Dallimore (1993-96) | 53 |
| 10. | Chris Minaker (2003-06) | 52 |
| | |
| Triples |
| 1. | Mike Codiroli (1976-79) | 19 |
| Mark Davis (1983-86) | 19 |
| 3. | Mike Dotterer (1980-83) | 16 |
| Sam Fuld (2001-04) | 16 |
| 5. | Ruben Amaro, Jr. (1984-87) | 15 |
| Jim Hibbs (1964-66) | 15 |
| A.J. Hinch (1993-96) | 15 |
| John Hurlbut (1959-61) | 15 |
| Mark Marquess (1967-69) | 15 |
| Jack Shepard (1951-53) | 15 |
| | |
| Home Runs |
| 1. | Paul Carey (1987-90) | 56 |
| 2. | Edmund Muth (1997-2000) | 51 |
| 3. | John Gall (1997-2000) | 46 |
| Josh Hochgesang (1996-99) | 46 |
| 5. | Rick Lundblade (1982-85) | 42 |
| 6. | David McCarty (1989-91) | 41 |
| Ed Sprague (1986-88) | 41 |
| 8. | Joe Borchard (1998-2000) | 40 |
| 9. | Ryan Garko (2000-03) | 39 |
| 10. | Tom Guardino (1975-78) | 37 |
| Eric Hardgrave (1980-83) | 37 |
| | |
| RBI |
| 1. | John Gall (1997-2000) | 263 |
| 2. | Paul Carey (1987-90) | 220 |
| 3. | Edmund Muth (1997-2000) | 208 |
| 4. | Tom Guardino (1975-78) | 203 |
| 5. | Josh Hochgesang (1996-99) | 200 |
| Rick Lundblade (1982-85) | 200 |
| 7. | Ryan Garko (2000-03) | 191 |
| A.J. Hinch (1993-96) | 191 |
| 9. | Mark Davis (1983-86) | 188 |
| 10. | Joe Borchard (1998-2000) | 187 |
| | |
| Walks |
| 1. | Pepe Hinojosa (1975-78) | 221 |
| 2. | Paul Carey (1987-90) | 190 |
| 3. | Ruben Amaro, Jr. (1984-87) | 187 |
| 4. | Pete Stanicek (1982-85) | 178 |
| 5. | Randy Wong (1975-78) | 174 |
| 6. | Mike Codiroli (1976-79) | 164 |
| 7. | Mike Nelson (1970-73) | 148 |
| 8. | Mark Davis (1983-86) | 143 |
| 9. | Mike Aldrete (1980-83) | 141 |
| Frank Carey (1986-89) | 141 |
| | |
| Stolen Bases |
| 1. | Larry Reynolds (1976-79) | 131 |
| 2. | Mike Codiroli (1976-79) | 108 |
| 3. | Pete Stanicek (1982-85) | 105 |
| 4. | Jeffrey Hammonds (1990-92) | 102 |
| 5. | Toi Cook (1984-87) | 85 |
| Mark Davis (1983-86) | 85 |
| Walt Harris (1983-86) | 85 |
| 8. | Ruben Amaro, Jr. (1984-87) | 80 |
| Mike Dotterer (1980-83) | 80 |
| 10. | Darryl Stephens (1981-84) | 69 |
| | |
| Hitting Streak |
| 1. | Jeffrey Hammonds (1990) | 37 |
| 2. | Troy Paulsen (1988) | 28 |
| 3. | Carlos Quentin (2003) | 26 |
| 4. | Austin Slater (2014) | 24 |
| Tyler Gaffney (2011-12) | 24 |
| 6. | Kenny Diekroeger (2010) | 23 |
| 7. | Brian Hall (2004) | 21 |
| 8. | Ryan Garko (2001) | 20 |
| 9. | Josh Hochgesang (1997) | 19 |
| 10. | Sam Fuld (2003) | 17 |
| | |
| ERA (min. 1.0 IP per team game played) |
| 1. | Frank Klinger (1966-68) | 1.05 |
| 2. | Harvey Shank (1967-69) | 1.37 |
| 3. | Rod Poteete (1967-69) | 1.50 |
| 4. | Sandy Vance (1967-68) | 1.70 |
| 5. | Steve Dunning (1969-70) | 2.06 |
| 6. | Bob DiPietro (1971-73) | 2.10 |
| 7. | Dan Shaw (1970-72) | 2.14 |
| 8. | Jim Coate (1969-71) | 2.17 |
| 9. | Phil Keller (1968-70) | 2.29 |
| 10. | Bruce Schoen (1969-1971) | 2.40 |
| | |
| Wins |
| 1. | Jeff Ballard (1982-85) | 37 |
| 2. | Jack McDowell (1985-87) | 35 |
| Kyle Peterson (1995-97) | 35 |
| 4. | Lee Plemel (1985-88) | 34 |
| 5. | Justin Wayne (1998-2000) | 31 |
| 6. | Mark Appel (2010-13) | 28 |
| Brian Mignano (1979-82) | 28 |
| Mark Romanczuk (2003-05) | 28 |
| 9. | Bruce Fiala (1976-79) | 27 |
| 10. | Jeremy Guthrie (2001-02) | 26 |
| Stan Spencer (1988-90) | 26 |
| | |
| Winning Percentage (min. 10 decisions) |
| 1. | Mike Wodnicki (1999-2001) | .933 (14-1) |
| 2. | Brian Sager (1999-2000) | .923 (12-1) |
| 3. | Gregg Lomnicky (1981-84) | .909 (10-1) |
| 4. | Frank Klinger (1966-68) | .867 (13-2) |
| 5. | Justin Wayne (1998-2000) | .861 (31-5) |
| 6. | Sandy Vance (1967-68) | .850 (17-3) |
| 7. | Joe Chez (1950-52) | .833 (20-4) |
| Rob Wassenaar (1984-87) | .833 (25-5) |
| 9. | Brian Sackinsky (1990-92) | .826 (19-4) |
| 10. | Jerry Argust (1974-77) | .818 (9-2) |
| Bruce Davis (1974-77) | .818 (9-2) |
| | |
| Saves (since 1973) |
| 1. | Jack Little (2017-19) | 28 |
| 2. | Steve Chitren (1986-89) | 26 |
| 3. | Colton Hock (2015-17) | 25 |
| 4. | Matt Manship (2003-06) | 17 |
| Scott Weiss (1988-91) | 17 |
| 6. | Jeff Bruksch (2000-01) | 16 |
| A.J. Vanegas (2011-14) | 16 |
| 8. | Drew Storen (2008-09) | 15 |
| Tony Cogan (1996-99) | 15 |
| Tom Reimers (1994-96) | 15 |
| | |
| Innings Pitched |
| 1. | Jeff Ballard (1982-85) | 428.0 |
| 2. | Lee Plemel (1985-88) | 422.0 |
| 3. | Kyle Peterson (1995-97) | 398.1 |
| 4. | Mark Appel (2010-13) | 377.2 |
| 5. | Stan Spencer (1988-90) | 374.0 |
| 6. | Jack McDowell (1985-87) | 372.2 |
| 7. | Justin Wayne (1998-2000) | 342.1 |
| 8. | Willie Adams (1991-93) | 329.2 |
| 9. | Mark Romanczuk (2003-05) | 329.1 |
| 10. | Mike Mussina (1988-90) | 328.1 |
| | |
| Strikeouts |
| 1. | Mark Appel (2010-13) | 372 |
| 2. | Kyle Peterson (1995-97) | 363 |
| Justin Wayne (1998-2000) | 363 |
| 4. | Jack McDowell (1985-87) | 337 |
| 5. | Jason Young (1998-2000) | 327 |
| 6. | Lee Plemel (1985-88) | 326 |
| 7. | Jeff Austin (1996-98) | 317 |
| 8. | Jeff Ballard (1982-85) | 316 |
| 9. | Stan Spencer (1988-90) | 297 |
| 10. | Steve Chitren (1986-89) | 278 |
