NSCAA |
1973 | Mac Taylor | | |
1974 | Bruce Mosbacher (Second Team) |
1975 | Bruce Mosbacher (Second Team) |
1978 | Dan McNevin (First Team) | |
1979 | Dan McNevin (First Team) | |
1981 | Jorge Titinger (First Team) | |
1982 | Jorge Titinger (First Team) | |
1983 | Giancarlo Ferruzzi (Second Team) |
1987 | Mark Semioli (Third Team) | |
1988 | Mark Semioli (First Team) | |
1992 | Ryan Collins | | |
1993 | Ryan Collins | | |
1996 | Jamie Clark (First Team) | |
| Dan Wytock (First Team) | |
1997 | Jamie Clark (First Team) | |
| Simon Elliott (Second Team) | |
| Shan Gaw (Second Team) | |
| Adam Zapala (Second Team) | |
1998 | Jamie Clark (First Team) | |
| Simon Elliott (First Team) | |
| Shan Gaw (First Team) | |
| Adam Zapala (Second Team) | |
1999 | Adam Zapala (First Team) | |
| Ryan Nelsen (First Team) | |
| Lee Morrison (Second Team) | |
2000 | Lee Morrison (First Team) | |
| Ryan Nelsen (First Team) | |
| Scott Leber (Second Team) | |
| Adam Zapala (Second Team) | |
2002 | Todd Dunivant (First Team) | |
| Roger Levesque (First Team) | |
| Taylor Graham (Third Team) | |
2005 | Chad Marshall (Second Team) | |
2006 | Darren Fernandez (Second Team) |
2006 | Galen Thompson (Third Team) | |
2007 | Scott Bolkan (First Team) | |
| Bobby Warshaw (Third Team) | |
2009 | Bobby Warshaw (First Team) | |
| Adam Jahn (Third Team) | |
| Michael Strickland (Third Team) |
2010 | Bobby Warshaw (Second Team) |
2011 | Adam Jahn (Third Team) | |
2012 | Adam Jahn (Second Team) | |
2013 | Zach Batteer (First Team) | |
| JJ Koval (First Team) | |
| Jordan Morris (Third Team) | |
2014 | Jordan Morris (First Team) | |
| Brandon Vincent (First Team) | |
| Corey Baird (Second Team) | |
| Tomas Hilliard-Arce (Third Team | |
2015 | Jordan Morris (First Team) | |
| Ty Thompson (First Team) | |
| Brandon Vincent (First Team) | |
| Andrew Epstein (Second Team) | |
| Eric Verso (Third Team) | |