| NSCAA | |
| 1953 | Samuel Suarez (Hon. Mention) |
| 1954 | Kenneth Woods (Hon. Mention) |
| 1955 | Peter Mack (Hon. Mention) |
| | James Montgomery (Hon. Mention) |
| 1958 | William Ditman (Hon. Mention) |
| 1960 | Bernie Naggs (Hon. Mention) |
| 1963 | Klas Bergman (Hon. Mention) |
| 1964 | Klas Bergman (Hon. Mention) |
| 1987 | Mark Semioli (Third Team) |
| 1997 | Jamie Clark (Second Team) |
| 1998 | Jamie Clark (First Team) |
| | Simon Elliott (Third Team) |
| 2000 | Ryan Nelsen (First Team) |
| | Lee Morrison (Second Team) |
| 2001 | Lee Morrison (First Team) |
| | Roger Levesque (Second Team) |
| 2002 | Todd Dunivant (First Team) |
| | Roger Levesque (Third Team) |
| 2009 | Bobby Warshaw (First Team) |
| 2014 | Jordan Morris (First Team) |
| | Brandon Vincent (First Team) |
| 2015 | Jordan Morris (First Team) |
| | Brandon Vincent (First Team) |
| | |
| College Soccer News |
| 1999 | Lee Morrison (Third Team) |
| 2002 | Todd Dunivant (First Team) |
| | Roger Levesque (Second Team) |
| | Johanes Maliza (Third Team) |
| | Taylor Graham (Hon. Mention) |
| 2014 | Brandon Vincent (Second Team) |
| | Jordan Morris (Third Team) |
| 2015 | Jordan Morris (First Team) |
| | Brandon Vincent (First Team) |
| | |
| College Soccer News All-Freshman |
| 2012 | Aaron Kovar (Third Team) |
| 2013 | Jordan Morris (Second Team) |
| 2014 | Corey Baird (First Team) |
| | Tomas Hilliard-Arce (Second Team) |
| | |
| TopDrawerSoccer.com Best XI |
| 2008 | Bobby Warshaw (Third Team) |
| 2009 | Bobby Warshaw (Second Team) |
| 2013 | JJ Koval (Second Team) |
| 2014 | Jordan Morris (First Team) |
| | Brandon Vincent (Second Team) |
| 2015 | Jordan Morris (First Team/POY) |
| | Brandon Vincent (First Team) |
| | Tomas Hilliard-Arce (Second Team) |
| | |
| TopDrawerSoccer.com Best XI Freshman |
| 2009 | Adam Jahn |
| 2013 | Jordan Morris (First Team) |
| 2014 | Tomas Hilliard-Arce (First Team) |
| | Corey Baird (Second Team) |
| | |
| Soccer America Men's MVP’s |
| 1988 | Mark Semioli |
| 2002 | Roger Levesque |
| 2014 | Jordan Morris (Second Team) |
| | Brandon Vincent (Second Team) |
| | |
| Soccer America All-Freshman |
| 1997 | Adam Zapala |
| 2002 | Chad Marshall |
| 2013 | Jordan Morris |
| 2014 | Corey Baird (First Team) |
| | Tomas Hilliard-Arce (Second Team) |
| | |
| Senior CLASS Award All-America |
| 2015 | Brandon Vincent (Second Team) |
