| California Conference |
| 1933 | Peter Knecht | |
| | Marshall Johnstone | |
| | John Moore | |
| 1934 | Waddy White | |
| 1935 | Barney Vierling (First Team) |
| | Bob Hall (Second Team) |
| | Paul Helms (Second Team) |
| | George Hatch (Second Team) |
| | Herb Sawyer (Second Team) |
| | Dave Sloane (Second Team) |
| | | | |
| Northern California Conference |
| 1936 | Louis Faulb (First Team) |
| | Bob Hall (First Team) |
| | George Hatch (First Team) |
| | Karl Schaupp (First Team) |
| 1937 | Louis Faulb (First Team) |
| | Karl Schaupp (First Team) |
| | Dave Sloane (First Team) |
| 1940 | Wilson Clark | |
| | George Dole | |
| 1947 | Godfrey Gregg | |
| | Randy Hudson | |
| | Homi Irani | |
| | Ricardo Trejos | |
| 1948 | Homi Irani (First Team) |
| | Lawrence Peterson (First Team) |
| 1949 | Ted Belknap (First Team) |
| | Amos Salvador (First Team) |
| | | | |
| California Conference |
| 1950 | R. Latham (First Team) |
| | | | |
| Northern California Conference |
| 1951 | Randy Rosso (First Team) |
| 1952 | Ronald Hall (First Team) |
| | Harry Havilio (First Team) |
| | Dick Keonigsberger (First Team) |
| | Derek Liecty (First Team) |
| | Randy Rosso (First Team) |
| | Ben Swan (First Team) |
| | Sam Suarez (First Team) |
| 1953 | Sam Suarez (First Team) |
| 1954 | Pete Mack (First Team) |
| | Niels Vinding (First Team) |
| 1955 | Peter Mack (First Team) |
| | James Montgomery (First Team) |
| | William Wren (First Team) |
| | Donald Yates (First Team) |
| 1957 | Michael Asafo-Boakye |
| | Bill Dittman | |
| | Keve Larson | |
| | Charles Lord | |
| 1959 | Bernie Knaggs (First Team) |
| | Wolfgang Storsch (First Team) |
| 1961 | Emmanuel Andah | |
| | Hunt Bascom | |
| | Albert Nnoli | |
| | Rusty Williams | |
| 1962 | Albert Nnoli (First Team) |
| | Bill Treush (First Team) |
| | Klas Bergman (Second Team) |
| | Stu Rawlings (Second Team) |
| | Ed Clark (Hon. Mention) |
| | Rich Lonergan (Hon. Mention) |
| | Kent Mueller (Hon. Mention) |
| | Sandy Pofahl (Hon. Mention) |
| 1963 | Klas Bergman (First Team) |
| | | | |
| Pacific-8 |
| 1970 | Linus Lau | | |
| | Carlos Quintana | |
| | Ben White | |
| 1973 | Mac Taylor | |
| | | | |
| West Coast Intercollegiate |
| 1966 | Knut Arnesen (First Team) |
| | John Cox (Second Team) |
| 1968 | Chip Jessup | |
| | Stan Holmgren | |
| | Carlos Quintana | |
| 1969 | Linus Lau (First Team) |
| | Chip Jessup (Hon. Mention) |
| | Ben White (Hon. Mention) |
| 1973 | Mac Taylor (First Team) |
| 1974 | Mac Taylor (First Team) |
| | Marty Glickfield (Second Team) |
| | Phil Wright (Second Team) |
| | Bruce Mosbacher (Hon. Mention) |
| | Robby Robb (Hon. Mention) |
| | Jim Stokes (Hon. Mention) |
| 1975 | Phil Wright (First Team) |
| | Bruce Mosbacher (Second Team) |
| | Marty Glickfield (Hon. Mention) |
| | Robby Robb (Hon. Mention) |
| | | | |
| Pacific Soccer Conference |
| 1977 | Dan McNevin (First Team) |
| | Bill Allstetter (Hon. Mention) |
| | Paul Kozachenko (Hon. Mention) |
| | Jim Melamed (Hon. Mention) |
| | Craig Ueland (Hon. Mention) |
| 1978 | Dan McNevin (First Team) |
| | Greg Delgado (Second Team) |
| | Ted Rafalovich (Second Team) |
| 1979 | Greg Delgado (First Team) |
| | Willie Guicci (Second Team) |
| | Dan McNevin (Second Team) |
| | Ted Rafalovich (Hon. Mention) |
| 1980 | Jorge Titinger (Second Team) |
| 1981 | Jorge Titinger (First Team) |
| | Angel Vazquez | |
| | Willie Burkhardt (Hon. Mention) |
| | Doug Clark (Hon. Mention) |
| | Walter Kingson (Hon. Mention) |
| 1982 | Jorge Titinger (First Team) |
| | Angel Vazquez | |
| | Walter Kingson (Hon. Mention) |
| 1983 | Tom Rafalovich (First Team) |
| | Willie Burkhardt (Second Team) |
| | Jorge Titinger (Second Team) |
| | Giancarlo Ferruzzi (Hon. Mention) |
| | Walter Kingson (Hon. Mention) |
| | Tom McGannon (Hon. Mention) |
| 1984 | Tom Rafalovich (Second Team) |
| | Rob West (Second Team) |
| 1985 | Todd Rafalovich (First Team) |
| | Angel Vasquez (First Team) |
| | Tom Austin (Second Team) |
| | Cassie Conceicao (Second Team) |
| | Tom Rafalovich (Second Team) |
| | Neal Stephens (Second Team) |
| 1986 | Mark Semioli (Second Team) |
| 1987 | Mark Semioli (First Team) |
| | Chris Porch (Hon. Mention) |
| | David Thorpe (Hon. Mention) |
| | | | |
| Mountain Pacific Sports Federation |
| 1992 | Ryan Collins (First Team) |
| | Randy Mann (First Team) |
| | Jason Vanacour (First Team) |
| | Robert Brophy (Second Team) |
| | Carmen D’Onofrio (Second Team) |
| 1993 | Niels Bruckner (First Team) |
| | Ryan Collins (First Team) |
| | Ricky Goad (First Team) |
| 1994 | Carmen D’Onofrio (First Team) |
| | Steve Kirschbaum (Second Team) |
| 1995 | Chet Zimmer (First Team) |
| | Carmen D’Onofrio (Second Team) |
| | Shan Gaw (Second Team) |
| 1996 | Jamie Clark (Hon. Mention) |
| | Shan Gaw (Hon. Mention) |
| | Steve Kirschbaum (Hon. Mention) |
| | A.J. Sauer (Hon. Mention) |
| 1997 | Jamie Clark (First Team) |
| | Simon Elliott (First Team) |
| | Adam Zapala (First Team) |
| | Shan Gaw (Hon. Mention) |
| | A.J. Sauer (Hon. Mention) |
| 1998 | Jamie Clark (Second Team) |
| | Simon Elliott First Team) |
| | Shan Gaw (Second Team) |
| | Lee Morrison (First Team) |
| | A.J. Sauer (Hon. Mention) |
| | Adam Zapala (Hon. Mention) |
| 1999 | Gerard Davis (First Team) |
| | Corey Woolfolk (First Team) |
| | Lee Morrison (First Team) |
| | T.K. Inbody (Second Team) |
| | Andy Hemmerich (Second Team) |
| | Ryan Nelsen (Second Team) |
| | Adam Zapala (Second Team) |
| | | | |
| Pac-10 |
| 2000 | Todd Dunivant (First Team) |
| | Scott Leber (First Team) |
| | Lee Morrison (First Team) |
| | Ryan Nelsen (First Team) |
| | Adam Zapala (First Team) |
| | Aaron Biddle (Second Team) |
| | Corey Woolfolk (Second Team) |
| | Roger Levesque (Hon. Mention) |
| | Johannes Maliza (Hon. Mention) |
| | Luke Rust (Hon. Mention) |
| | Derek Shanahan (Hon. Mention) |
| | Sean Sylvis (Hon. Mention) |
| 2001 | Todd Dunivant (First Team) |
| | Roger Levesque (First Team) |
| | Lee Morrison (First Team) |
| | Derek Shanahan (First Team) |
| | Abe Geiger (Second Team) |
| | Johanes Maliza (Second Team) |
| | Aaron Biddle (Hon. Mention) |
| | Taylor Graham (Hon. Mention) |
| | Andrew Terris (Hon. Mention) |
| 2002 | Taylor Graham (First Team) |
| | Roger Levesque (First Team) |
| | Johanes Maliza (First Team) |
| | Todd Dunivant (Second Team) |
| | Chad Marshall (Second Team) |
| | Darren Fernandez (Hon. Mention) |
| | Robby Fulton (Hon. Mention) |
| | James Twellman (Hon. Mention) |
| 2003 | Chad Marshall (First Team) |
| | Mike Wilson (Second Team) |
| | Darren Fernandez (Hon. Mention) |
| | Robby Fulton (Hon. Mention) |
| | Abe Geiger (Hon. Mention) |
| | Matt Janusz (Hon. Mention) |
| | James Twellman (Hon. Mention) |
| 2004 | Darren Fernandez (First Team) |
| | Cooper McKee (Second Team) |
| | Matt Janusz (Second Team) |
| | Robby Fulton (Hon. Mention) |
| | Aaron Maines (Hon. Mention) |
| | James Twellman (Hon. Mention) |
| | Seyi Abolaji (Hon. Mention) |
| | Michael Brown (Hon. Mention) |
| 2005 | Cooper McKee (Second Team) |
| | Michael Brown (Hon. Mention) |
| | Scott Bolkan (Hon. Mention) |
| | Andrew Kartunen (Hon. Mention) |
| | T.J. Novack (Hon. Mention) |
| | Marcus Ryan (Hon. Mention) |
| | Dan Shapiro (Hon. Mention) |
| 2006 | Scott Bolkan (Second Team) |
| | Evan Morgan (Second Team) |
| | Galen Thompson (Second Team) |
| | Kyle Hency (Hon. Mention) |
| | John Moore (Hon. Mention) |
| | T.J. Novak (Hon. Mention) |
| | Dan Shapiro (Hon. Mention) |
| | Bret Shimizu (Hon. Mention) |
| 2007 | Scott Bolkan (First Team) |
| | John Moore (Second Team) |
| | Michael Strickland (Second Team) |
| | Bobby Warshaw (Second Team) |
| | Kyle Hency (Hon. Mention) |
| | Ryan Imamura (Hon. Mention) |
| | Andrew Kartunen (Hon. Mention) |
| | T.J. Novak (Hon. Mention) |
| | Dan Shapiro (Hon. Mention) |
| 2008 | Michael Strickland (First Team) |
| | Bobby Warshaw (First Team) |
| | Ryan Imamura (Second Team) |
| | Garrett Gunther (Hon. Mention) |
| | Tim Jones (Hon. Mention) |
| | John Moore (Hon. Mention) |
| | Ryan Thomas (Hon. Mention) |
| 2009 | Michael Strickland (First Team) |
| | Bobby Warshaw (First Team) |
| | Adam Jahn (Second Team) |
| | Evan Morgan (Second Team) |
| | John Moore (Hon. Mention) |
| | T.J. Novak (Hon. Mention) |
| | Ryan Thomas (Hon. Mention) |
| 2010 | Bobby Warshaw (First Team) |
| | Adam Jahn (Second Team) |
| | Ryan Thomas (Second Team) |
| | Dominique Yahyavi (Second Team) |
| | Cameron Lamming (Honorable Mention) |
| | | | |
| Pac-12 |
| 2011 | Garrett Gunther (First Team) |
| | Adam Jahn (Second Team) |
| | JJ Koval (Honorable Mention) |
| 2012 | Adam Jahn (First Team) |
| | Hunter Gorskie (Second Team) |
| | Aaron Kovar (Second Team) |
| | Dersu Abolfathi (Honorable Mention) |
| | Zach Batteer (Honorable Mention) |
| | JJ Koval (Honorable Mention) |
| 2013 | Zach Batteer (First Team) |
| | JJ Koval (First Team) |
| | Jordan Morris (First Team) |
| | Brandon Vincent (Second Team) |
| | Ty Conklin (Honorable Mention) |
| | Drew Hutchins (Honorable Mention) |
| | Aaron Kovar (Honorable Mention) |
| | Ty Thompson (Honorable Mention) |
| 2014 | Jordan Morris (First Team) |
| | Brandon Vincent (First Team) |
| | Corey Baird (Second Team) |
| | Zach Batteer (Second Team) |
| | Andrew Epstein (Second Team) |
| | Tomas Hilliard-Arce (Second Team) |
| | Austin Meyer (Second Team) |
| | Ty Thompson (Honorable Mention) |
| 2015 | Jordan Morris (First Team) |
| | Ty Thompson (First Team) |
| | Brandon Vincent (First Team) |
| | Corey Baird (Second Team) |
| | Andrew Epstein (Second Team) |
| | Tomas Hilliard-Arce (Second Team) |
| | Foster Langsdorf (Second Team) |
| | Eric Verso (Second Team) |
