| Goals | ||
| 1. | Bret Bonanni (2012-15) | 360 |
| 2. | Tony Azevedo (2001-04) | 332 |
| 3. | Alex Bowen (2011-14) | 253 |
| 4. | James Bergeson (1979-81) | 235 |
| 5. | Jody Campbell (1978-81) | 211 |
| 6. | Wolf Wigo (1991-94) | 203 |
| 7. | Erich Fischer (1985-87) | 197 |
| 8. | Ben Hallock (2017-20) | 194 |
| 9. | Craig Klass (1983-86) | 184 |
| 10. | Jeremy Laster (1992-95) | 183 |