| 2022 (2) | Kyla Bryant (Floor, 1st; AA, honorable mention) |
| 2020 (2) | Kyla Bryant (AA, 1st; Floor, 1st) |
| 2019 (2) | Kyla Bryant (AA, 2nd; Floor, 2nd) |
| 2018 (3) | Elizabeth Price (AA, 1st; Bars, 1st; Floor, 1st; Vault, 1st) |
| 2017 (4) | Rachel Daum (AA, 2nd) |
| Elizabeth Price (Vault, 1st; Bars, 1st; Floor, 2nd) |
| 2016 (4) | Melissa Chuang (Beam, 1st) |
| Ivana Hong (Beam, 2nd) |
| Elizabeth Price (AA, 1st) |
| Taylor Rice (AA, 2nd) |
| 2015 (4) | Ivana Hong (Bars, 1st) |
| Elizabeth Price (Vault, 1st) |
| Taylor Rice (AA, 1st) |
| Samantha Shapiro (Bars, 2nd) |
| 2014 (5) | Nicolette McNair (Vault, 1st; Bars, 1st) |
| Samantha Shapiro (Bars, 2nd) |
| Amanda Spinner (Beam, 2nd) |
| Kristina Vaculik (AA, 1st) |
| 2013 (3) | Nicole Dayton (Vault, 2nd) |
| Ivana Hong (Beam, 1st) |
| Ashley Morgan (AA, 1st) |
| 2012 (4) | Ivana Hong (Vault, 2nd) |
| Ashley Morgan (Bars, 1st; Floor, 1st) |
| Shona Morgan (Beam, 2nd) |
| 2011 (5) | Shelly Alexander (AA, 1st) |
| Alyssa Brown (Beam, 1st) |
| Danielle Ikoma (AA, 1st) |
| Ashley Morgan (Floor, 1st) |
| Nicole Pechanec (Floor, 2nd) |
| 2010 (5) | Alyssa Brown (Beam, 2nd) |
| Allyse Ishino (Bars, 2nd) |
| Carly Janiga (AA, 1st) |
| Ashley Morgan (Floor, 2nd) |
| Nicole Pechanec (Floor, 2nd) |
| 2009 (7) | Shelly Alexander (Vault, 1st; Floor, 1st) |
| Kelly Fee (Bars, 2nd; Floor, 2nd) |
| Allyse Ishino (Beam, 1st) |
| Carly Janiga (AA, 1st) |
| Nicole Ourada (Bars, 2nd) |
| 2008 (4) | Lauren Elmore (Floor, 2nd) |
| Allyse Ishino (Bars, 1st) |
| Tabitha Yim (Bars, 1st; Beam, 1st) |
| 2007 (5) | Kelly Fee (Beam, 1st) |
| Carly Janiga (Bars, 1st; Floor, 1st) |
| Nicole Ourada (Floor, 1st) |
| Tabitha Yim (Bars, 1st) |
| 2006 (7) | Natalie Foley (AA, 1st) |
| Liz Tricase (Vault, 1st; Bars, 1st) |
| Tabitha Yim (Vault, 1st; Bars, 1st; Beam, 1st; Floor, 1st) |
| 2005 (2) | Natalie Foley (AA, 1st) |
| Tabitha Yim (Bars, 1st) |
| 2004 (4) | Caroline Fluhrer (Bars, 1st) |
| Natalie Foley (AA, 1st; Vault, 1st) |
| Lindsay Wing (Beam, 1st) |
| 2003 (3) | Natalie Foley (AA, 1st) |
| Lise Léveillé (AA, 1st) |
| Lindsay Wing (Beam, 1st) |
| 2002 (1) | Lise Léveillé (Beam, 1st) |
| 2001 (8) | Jennifer Exaltacion (AA, 1st; Beam, 1st) |
| Caroline Fluhrer (AA, 1st; Vault, 1st) |
| Lise Léveillé (Beam, 1st; Floor, 1st) |
| Lindsay Wing (Beam, 1st; AA, 1st) |
| 2000 (3) | Larissa Fontaine (AA, 1st; Vault, 1st; Bars, 1st) |
| 1999 (1) | Amy Murakami (Floor, 1st) |
| 1997 (4) | Larissa Fontaine (AA, 1st; Bars, 1st) |
| Amy Murakami (AA, 1st; Bars, 1st) |
| 1996 (2) | Keri Monahan (AA, 1st) |
| Amy Murakami (Floor, 1st) |
| 1995 (1) | Jene Elzie (AA, 1st) |
| 1994 (1) | Jene Elzie (AA, 1st) |
| 1992 (1) | Jene Elzie |
| 1988 (1) | Dina Amoroso |
