| NCAA All-Tournament Team | ||
| Tyler Abramson | First Team | 2020 |
| AJ Rossman | Second Team | 2020 |
| Quinn Woodhead | Second Team | 2020 |
| Ben Hallock ** | First Team | 2019 |
| Tyler Abramson | First Team | 2019 |
| AJ Rossman | Second Team | 2019 |
| Quinn Woodhead | Second Team | 2019 |
| Bennett Williams | Second Team | 2019 |
| Andrew Chun | Second Team | 2019 |
| Ben Hallock | First Team | 2018 |
| Bennett Williams | First Team | 2018 |
| Blake Parrish | First Team | 2018 |
| Tyler Abramson | Second Team | 2018 |
| Bret Bonanni | First Team | 2014 |
| Alex Bowen | First Team | 2014 |
| BJ Churnside | Second Team | 2014 |
| Bret Bonanni | First Team | 2013 |
| Alex Bowen | First Team | 2013 |
| BJ Churnside | Second Team | 2013 |
| Drac Wigo | First Team | 2008 |
| Sage Wright | First Team | 2008 |
| Will Hindle-Katel | Second Team | 2008 |
| Jimmie Sandman | Second Team | 2008 |
| Janson Wigo | Second Team | 2008 |
| Thomas Hopkins | First Team | 2005 |
| Peter Varellas | First Team | 2005 |
| J.J. Garton | Second Team | 2005 |
| Will Hindle-Katel | Second Team | 2005 |
| Sandy Hohener | Second Team | 2005 |
| Tony Azevedo | First Team | 2004 |
| Greg Crum | First Team | 2004 |
| Thomas Hopkins | First Team | 2004 |
| Peter Varellas | First Team | 2004 |
| Tony Azevedo ** | -- | 2003 |
| Mike Derse | -- | 2003 |
| Peter Varellas | -- | 2003 |
| Tony Azevedo ** | -- | 2002 |
| Nick Ellis | -- | 2002 |
| Peter Hudnut | -- | 2002 |
| Tony Azevedo ** | -- | 2001 |
| Nick Ellis | -- | 2001 |
| Peter Hudnut | -- | 2001 |
| Jeff Nesmith | -- | 2001 |
| Nick Ellis | -- | 1999 |
| Brian Heifferon | -- | 1999 |
| Jonathan Skaalen | -- | 1999 |
| Chris Aguilera ** | -- | 1998 |
| Layne Beaubien | -- | 1998 |
| Brian Heifferon | -- | 1998 |
| Jack Bowen ** | -- | 1994 |
| Jeremy Laster ** | -- | 1994 |
| Frank Schneider ** | -- | 1994 |
| Wolf Wigo | -- | 1994 |
| Larry Bercutt ** | -- | 1993 |
| Antonio Busquets | -- | 1993 |
| Wolf Wigo | -- | 1993 |
| Larry Bercutt | -- | 1992 |
| Chip Blankenhorn | -- | 1992 |
| Colin Keely | -- | 1990 |
| Rick McNair | -- | 1990 |
| Rick McNair | -- | 1989 |
| Jeff Oeding | -- | 1989 |
| Eric Fischer | -- | 1987 |
| David Imbernino ** | -- | 1986 |
| Craig Klass ** | -- | 1986 |
| Eric Fischer | -- | 1986 |
| David Imbernino ** | -- | 1985 |
| Craig Klass | -- | 1985 |
| Craig Klass | -- | 1984 |
| James Bergeson ** | -- | 1982 |
| John Tanner | -- | 1982 |
| James Bergeson ** | -- | 1981 |
| Jody Campbell ** | -- | 1981 |
| Chris Kelsey | -- | 1981 |
| Alan Mouchawar | -- | 1981 |
| Vince Vannelli | -- | 1981 |
| John Gansel ** | -- | 1980 |
| James Bergeson | -- | 1980 |
| Jody Campbell | -- | 1980 |
| Chris Kelsey | -- | 1980 |
| Alan Mouchawar | -- | 1980 |
| Randy Kalbus | -- | 1979 |
| Robby Arnold | -- | 1978 |
| Doug Burke | -- | 1978 |
| John Gansel | -- | 1978 |
| Marty Davis | -- | 1977 |
| John Gansel | -- | 1977 |
| Chris Dorst ** | -- | 1976 |
| Rob Arnold | -- | 1976 |
| Rick Johannsen | -- | 1976 |
| Drew McDonald | -- | 1976 |
| ** MVP | ||
| MPSF All-Tournament Team | ||
| Jackson Painter | -- | 2022 |
| Quinn Woodhead | -- | 2022 |
| Tyler Abramson | -- | 2021 |
| AJ Rossman | -- | 2021 |
| Andrew Chun ** | -- | 2020 |
| Tyler Abramson | -- | 2020 |
| Quinn Woodhead | -- | 2020 |
| Ben Hallock ** | -- | 2019 |
| Tyler Abramson | -- | 2019 |
| Andrew Chun | -- | 2019 |
| Ben Hallock ** | -- | 2018 |
| Tyler Abramson | -- | 2018 |
| Blake Parrish | -- | 2018 |
| Blake Parrish | -- | 2016 |
| Bret Bonanni | -- | 2015 |
| Alex Bowen ** | -- | 2014 |
| Bret Bonanni | -- | 2014 |
| BJ Churnside | -- | 2014 |
| Drew Holland | -- | 2014 |
| Bret Bonanni | -- | 2013 |
| Alex Bowen | -- | 2013 |
| Alex Bowen | -- | 2012 |
| BJ Churnside | -- | 2012 |
| Forrest Watkins | -- | 2011 |
| Jeffrey Schwimer | -- | 2010 |
| Jacob Smith | -- | 2010 |
| Sage Wright | -- | 2010 |
| Jimmie Sandman | -- | 2009 |
| Drac Wigo | -- | 2009 |
| Drac Wigo | -- | 2008 |
| Janson Wigo | -- | 2008 |
| J.J. Garton | -- | 2006 |
| Thomas Hopkins | -- | 2005 |
| Peter Varellas | -- | 2005 |
| ** MVP | ||