| MPSF All-Conference | ||
| Jackson Painter | First Team | 2023 |
| Riley Pittman | Second Team | 2023 |
| Ethan Parrish | Second Team | 2023 |
| Soren Jensen | Honorable Mention | 2023 |
| Quinn Woodhead | First Team | 2022 |
| Nolan Krutonog | Second Team | 2022 |
| Jackson Painter | Second Team | 2022 |
| Larsen Weigle | Second Team | 2022 |
| Riley Pittman | Honorable Mention | 2022 |
| Tyler Abramson | First Team | 2021 |
| AJ Rossman | First Team | 2021 |
| Quinn Woodhead | Second Team | 2021 |
| Beck Jurasius | Honorable Mention | 2021 |
| Tyler Abramson | First Team | 2020 |
| Quinn Woodhead | First Team | 2020 |
| Beck Jurasius | Second Team | 2020 |
| Andrew Chun | Honorable Mention | 2020 |
| Soren Jensen | Honorable Mention | 2020 |
| Ethan Parrish | Honorable Mention | 2020 |
| Tyler Abramson | First Team | 2019 |
| Andrew Chun | First Team | 2019 |
| Ben Hallock | First Team | 2019 |
| Bennett Williams | First Team | 2019 |
| AJ Rossman | Second Team | 2019 |
| Dylan Woodhead | Honorable Mention | 2019 |
| Quinn Woodhead | Honorable Mention | 2019 |
| Ben Hallock | First Team | 2018 |
| Blake Parrish | First Team | 2018 |
| Bennett Williams | First Team | 2018 |
| Oliver Lewis | Second Team | 2018 |
| Tyler Abramson | Honorable Mention | 2018 |
| Ben Hallock | First Team | 2017 |
| Connor Stapleton | First Team | 2017 |
| Drew Holland | Second Team | 2017 |
| Blake Parrish | Honorable Mention | 2017 |
| Cody Smith | Honorable Mention | 2017 |
| Blake Parrish | First Team | 2016 |
| Cody Smith | Second Team | 2016 |
| Oliver Lewis | Honorable Mention | 2016 |
| Bennett Williams | Honorable Mention | 2016 |
| Bret Bonanni | First Team | 2015 |
| Adam Abdulhamid | Honorable Mention | 2015 |
| BJ Churnside | Honorable Mention | 2015 |
| Bret Bonanni | First Team | 2014 |
| Alex Bowen | First Team | 2014 |
| BJ Churnside | Second Team | 2014 |
| Drew Holland | Second Team | 2014 |
| Conner Cleary | Honorable Mention | 2014 |
| Nick Hoversten | Honorable Mention | 2014 |
| Alex Bowen | First Team | 2013 |
| Bret Bonanni | Second Team | 2013 |
| Forrest Watkins | Second Team | 2013 |
| BJ Churnside | Honorable Mention | 2013 |
| Bret Bonanni | First Team | 2012 |
| Alex Bowen | First Team | 2012 |
| BJ Churnside | Honorable Mention | 2012 |
| Forrest Watkins | Honorable Mention | 2012 |
| Alex Bowen | First Team | 2011 |
| Forrest Watkins | First Team | 2011 |
| Jacob Smith | Second Team | 2011 |
| Brian Pingree | Honorable Mention | 2011 |
| Peter Sefton | Honorable Mention | 2011 |
| Jeffrey Schwimer | First Team | 2010 |
| Jacob Smith | Second Team | 2010 |
| Sage Wright | Second Team | 2010 |
| Paul Rudolph | Honorable Mention | 2010 |
| Peter Sefton | Honorable Mention | 2010 |
| Jimmie Sandman | First Team | 2009 |
| Drac Wigo | First Team | 2009 |
| Janson Wigo | First Team | 2009 |
| Jimmie Sandman | First Team | 2008 |
| Sage Wright | First Team | 2008 |
| Drac Wigo | Second Team | 2008 |
| Janson Wigo | Second Team | 2008 |
| Will Hindle-Katel | Honorable Mention | 2008 |
| Sage Wright | First Team | 2007 |
| Will Hindle-Katel | Third Team | 2007 |
| Sandy Hohener | Third Team | 2007 |
| Drac Wigo | Third Team | 2007 |
| Janson Wigo | Third Team | 2007 |
| Michael Bury | Honorable Mention | 2007 |
| Will Hindle-Katel | First Team | 2006 |
| J.J. Garton | Third Team | 2006 |
| Janson Wigo | Third Team | 2006 |
| Tyler Drake | Honorable Mention | 2006 |
| Drac Wigo | Honorable Mention | 2006 |
| Sandy Hohener | First Team | 2005 |
| Thomas Hopkins | First Team | 2005 |
| Peter Varellas | First Team | 2005 |
| J.J. Garton | Honorable Mention | 2005 |
| Will Hindle-Katel | Honorable Mention | 2005 |
| Tony Azevedo | First Team | 2004 |
| Chad Taylor | First Team | 2004 |
| Peter Varellas | First Team | 2004 |
| Thomas Hopkins | Second Team | 2004 |
| Greg Crum | Third Team | 2004 |
| Tony Azevedo | First Team | 2003 |
| Mike Derse | Second Team | 2003 |
| Chad Taylor | Second Team | 2003 |
| Thomas Hopkins | Third Team | 2003 |
| Greg Crum | Honorable Mention | 2003 |
| Peter Varellas | Honorable Mention | 2003 |
| Tony Azevedo | First Team | 2002 |
| Peter Hudnut | First Team | 2002 |
| Jeff Nesmith | Second Team | 2002 |
| Nick Ellis | Third Team | 2002 |
| Mike Derse | Honorable Mention | 2002 |
| Tony Azevedo | First Team | 2001 |
| Nick Ellis | First Team | 2001 |
| Peter Hudnut | First Team | 2001 |
| Jeff Nesmith | Third Team | 2001 |
| Peter Darrow | Honorable Mention | 2001 |
| Pasi Dutton | Honorable Mention | 2001 |
| Brian Heifferon | First Team | 1999 |
| Nick Ellis | First Team | 1999 |
| Sean Joy | Second Team | 1999 |
| Andy Walburger | Third Team | 1999 |
| Jon Skaalen | Honorable Mention | 1999 |
| Layne Beaubien | First Team | 1998 |
| Brian Heifferon | Second Team | 1998 |
| Brian Wallin | First Team | 1996 |
| Chris Aguilera | Second Team | 1996 |
| Dan Lehoczky | Third Team | 1996 |
| Jack Bowen | Second Team | 1995 |
| Jeremy Laster | Second Team | 1995 |
| Brian Wallin | Second Team | 1995 |