| Artistic Swimming (7) | Miko Begossi | USAAS Collegiate All-American |
| Ivy Davis | USAAS Collegiate All-American |
| Yara Elian | USAAS Collegiate All-American |
| Nicole Goot | USAAS Collegiate All-American |
| Hailee Heinrich | USAAS Collegiate All-American |
| Lindi Schroeder | USAAS Collegiate All-American |
| Hailee Heinrich | USAAS Collegiate All-American |
| Emmanuella Tchakmakjian | USAAS Collegiate All-American |
| Baseball (5) | Ryan Bruno | College Baseball Foundation Second Team |
| Alberto Rios | Collegiate Baseball First Team, College Baseball Foundation Second Team, ABCA First Team, Perfect Game Second Team, NCBWA First Team, Baseball America First Team, D1 Baseball First Team |
| Braden Montgomery | ABCA Second Team |
| Quinn Mathews | Collegiate Baseball Second Team, College Baseball Foundation First Team, ABCA First Team, Perfect Game First Team, NCBWA First Team, Baseball America Second Team, D1 Baseball First Team |
| Tommy Troy | ABCA Second Team, Perfect Game First Team, Baseball America Third Team, D1 Baseball Third Team |
| Women's Basketball (2) | Cameron Brink | WBCA, Associated Press Second Team, USBWA Second Team, Wooden Award |
| Haley Jones | Associated Press Third Team, USBWA Third Team |
| Beach Volleyball (2) | Xolani Hodel | AVCA Second Team |
| Maddi Kriz | AVCA Second Team |
| Men's Cross Country (2) | Charles Hicks | NCAA |
| Ky Robinson | NCAA |
| Women's Cross Country (1) | Zofia Dudek | NCAA |
| Women's Fencing (1) | Irene Yeu | NCAA Epee Honorable Mention |
| Football (1) | Joshua Karty | Sporting News First Team, FWAA Second Team, Associated Press Third Team |
| Men's Golf (3) | Michael Thorbjornsen | PING First Team |
| Barclay Brown | PING Honorable Mention |
| Karl Vilips | PING Honorable Mention |
| Women's Golf (3) | Rose Zhang | WGCA First Team |
| Sadie Englemann | WGCA Second Team |
| Megha Ganne | WGCA Honorable Mention |
| Men's Gymnastics (7) | Brandon Briones | NCAA Still Rings |
| Taylor Burkhart | NCAA Vault, Horizontal Bar |
| J.R. Chou | NCAA Pommel Horse, Horizontal Bar |
| Asher Hong | NCAA Still Rings, Vault, All-Around |
| Nicolas Kuebler | NCAA Floor, Still Rings |
| Brandon Nguyen | NCAA Parallel Bars |
| Khoi Young | NCAA Vault |
| Women's Gymnastics (1) | Chloe Widner | NCAA Beam First Team |
| Lightweight Rowing (2) | Juliette Lermsiaux | CRCA First Team |
| Hannah Justicz | CRCA First Team |
| Sailing (7) | Hannah Freeman | ICSA Woman Skipper |
| Michelle Lahrkamp | ICSA Woman Skipper, ICSA Open Skipper |
| Vanessa Lahrkamp | ICSA Woman Skipper, ICSA Open Skipper |
| Patricia Gerli | ICSA Crew |
| Ellie Harned | ICSA Crew |
| Abigail Tindall | ICSA Crew |
| Grace Austin | ICSA Crew Honorable Mention |
| Men's Soccer (1) | Keegan Hughes | United Soccer Coaches First Team |
| Softball (1) | Alana Vawter | NFCA Second Team |
| Squash (1) | Si Yi Ma | CSA Second Team |
| Men's Swimming and Diving (11) | Jonathan Affeld | CSCAA 200 Freestyle Relay Second Team |
| Andres Dupont | CSCAA 400 Freestyle Relay First Team |
| Preston Forst | CSCAA 800 Freestyle Relay First Team |
| Ethan Foster | CSCAA Platform Diving Second Team |
| Rafael Gu | ICSA Crew |
| Leon MacAlister | CSCAA 200 Medley Relay Second Team, 400 Medley Relay Second Team |
| Luke Maurer | CSCAA 200 Freestyle Second Team, 200 Freestyle Relay Second Team, 400 Freestyle Relay First Team, 400 Medley Relay Second Team, 800 Freestyle Relay First Team |
| Andrei Minakov | CSCAA 100 Butterfly First Team, 200 Freestyle Relay Second Team, 200 Medley Relay Second Team, 400 Freestyle Relay First Team, 400 Medley Relay Second Team, 800 Freestyle Relay First Team |
| Ron Polonsky | CSCAA 100 Breastroke Second Team, 200 Individual Medley First Team, 200 Medley Relay Second Team, 400 Freestyle Relay First Team, 400 Medley Relay Second Team, 800 Freestyle Relay First Team |
| Jack Ryan | CSCAA 1-meter Diving First Team |
| Aaron Sequeira | CSCAA 100 Butterfly Second Team, 200 Backstroke Second Team |
| Women's Swimming and Diving (14) | Lucy Bell | CSCAA 400 Individual Medley First Team, 200 Individual Medley Second Team |
| Claire Curzan | CSCAA 200 Freestyle Relay First Team, 100 Butterfly First Team, 100 Backstroke First Team, 400 Medley Relay First Team, 200 Backstroke First Team, 400 Freestyle Relay First Team, 200 Medley Relay Second Team |
| Charlotte Hook | CSCAA 200 Butterfly First Team |
| Torri Huske | CSCAA 800 Freestyle Relay First Team, 200 Individual Medley First Team, 200 Freestyle Relay First Team, 100 Butterfly First Team, 400 Medley Relay First Team, 100 Freestyle First Team, 400 Free Relay First Team |
| Natalie Mannion | CSCAA 500 Freestyle Second Team |
| Lillie Nordmann | CSCAA 800 Freestyle Relay First Team, 200 Butterfly Second Team |
| Lucie Nordmann | CSCAA 100 Backstroke Second Team, 200 Backstroke Second Team |
| Allie Raab | CSCAA 400 Medley Relay First Team, 200 Medley Relay Second Team |
| Taylor Ruck | CSCAA 800 Freestyle Relay First Team, 200 Freestyle Relay First Team, 200 Freestyle First Team, 400 Medley Relay First Team, 400 Freestyle Relay First Team |
| Sam Tadder | CSCAA 400 Individual Medley Second Team |
| Amy Tang | CSCAA 200 Freestyle Relay First Team, 400 Freestyle Relay First Team, 200 Medley Relay Second Team |
| Morgan Tankersley | CSCAA 200 Freestyle Second Team |
| Emma Wheal | CSCAA 200 Medley Relay Second Team |
| Lucie Nordmann | CSCAA (200 Back, 100 Back) |
| Kayla Wilson | CSCAA 800 Freestyle Relay First Team, 200 Freestyle First Team |
| Women's Soccer (1) | Maya Doms | United Soccer Coaches Second Team |
| Men's Tennis (2) | Nishesh Basavareddy | ITA All-American |
| Arthur Fery | ITA All-American |
| Women's Tennis (2) | Angelica Blake | ITA All-American |
| Alexandra Yepifanova | ITA All-American |
| Men's Indoor Track and Field (7) | Ky Robinson | NCAA 5,000 meters (First team), 3,000 meters (Second Team) |
| Garrett Brown | NCAA pole vault (First Team) |
| Udodi Onwuzurike | NCAA 200 meters (First Team) |
| Charles Hicks | NCAA First Team (3,000 meters) |
| Devin Hart | NCAA 5,000 meters (Second Team) |
| Charles Hicks | NCAA 5,000 meters (Second Team) |
| John Lester | NCAA 800 meters (Second Team) |
| Max McKhann | NCAA weight throw (Second Team) |
| Women's Indoor Track and Field (7) | Alyssa Jones | NCAA long jump (First Team) |
| Melissa Tanaka | NCAA distance medley relay (First Team) |
| Roisin Willis | NCAA 800 meters (First Team), DMR (First Team), 4x400 meter relay (Second Team) |
| Juliette Whittaker | NCAA 800 meters (First Team), DMR (First Team), 4x400 meter relay (Second Team) |
| Maya Valmon | NCAA DMR (First Team), 4x400 meter relay (Second Team) |
| Zofia Dudek | NCAA 5,000 meters (Second Team) |
| Alexa Rossum | NCAA 4x400 relay (Second Team) |
| Men's Outdoor Track and Field (3) | Charles Hicks | NCAA 5,000 meters (First Team), 10,000 meters (First Team) |
| Udodi Onwuzurike | NCAA 100 meters (First Team), 200 meters (First Team) |
| Ky Robinson | NCAA 5,000 meters (First Team), 10,000 meters (First Team) |
| Women's Outdoor Track and Field (7) | Alyssa Jones | NCAA long jump (First Team), 4x100 meters (Second Team) |
| Roisin Willis | NCAA 800 meters (First Team) |
| Lucy Jenks | 5,000 meters (Second Team) |
| Alexa Rossum | 4x100 meters (Second Team), 4x400 meters (Second Team) |
| Maya Valmon | 4x100 meters (Second Team), 4x400 meters (Second Team) |
| Cydney Wright | 4x100 meters (Second Team), 4x400 meters (Second Team) |
| Juliette Whittaker | 4x100 meters (Second Team) |
| Men's Volleyball (2) | Will Rottman | AVCA Second Team |
| Justin Lui | AVCA Honorable Mention |
| Women's Volleyball (3) | Kendall Kipp | AVCA First Team |
| Kami Miner | AVCA First Team |
| Elena Oglivie | AVCA Honorable Mention |
| Men's Water Polo (2) | Quinn Woodhead | ACWPC First Team |
| Jackson Painter | ACWPC Second Team |
| Wrestling (1) | Shane Griffith | NCAA |
| Women's Water Polo (5) | Maya Avital | ACWPC First Team |
| Aria Fischer | ACWPC First Team |
| Ryann Neushul | ACWPC First Team |
| Jenna Flynn | ACWPC Second Team |
| Jewel Roemer | ACWPC Second Team |
