NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches
| Year | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Zach Bohane | First Team |
| 2023 | Mark Fisher | First Team |
| 2023 | Noah Adnan | Third Team |
| 2023 | Shane de Flores | Third Team |
| 2022 | Cam Cilley | First Team |
| 2022 | Keegan Hughes | First Team |
| 2021 | Ousseni Bouda | First Team |
| 2021 | Zach Ryan | Second Team |
| 2020 | Zach Ryan | First Team |
| 2020 | Andrew Thomas | Second Team |
| 2020 | Charlie Wehan | Second Team |
| 2019 | Tanner Beason | First Team |
| 2019 | Andrew Thomas | First Team |
| 2019 | Derek Waldeck | First Team |
| 2019 | Ousseni Bouda | Second Team |
| 2018 | Amir Bashti | First Team |
| 2018 | Tanner Beason | First Team |
| 2018 | Andrew Thomas | First Team |
| 2018 | Logan Panchot | Third Team |
| 2017 | Corey Baird | First Team |
| 2017 | Tomas Hilliard-Arce | First Team |
| 2017 | Foster Langsdorf | First Team |
| 2017 | Drew Skundrich | First Team |
| 2017 | Nico Corti | Third Team |
| 2016 | Andrew Epstein | First Team |
| 2016 | Tomas Hilliard-Arce | First Team |
| 2016 | Foster Langsdorf | First Team |
| 2016 | Brian Nana-Sinkam | Second Team |
| 2016 | Drew Skundrich | Second Team |
| 2015 | Jordan Morris | First Team |
| 2015 | Ty Thompson | First Team |
| 2015 | Brandon Vincent | First Team |
| 2015 | Andrew Epstein | Second Team |
| 2015 | Eric Verso | Third Team |
| 2014 | Jordan Morris | First Team |
| 2014 | Brandon Vincent | First Team |
| 2014 | Corey Baird | Second Team |
| 2014 | Tomas Hilliard-Arce | Third Team |
| 2013 | Zach Batteer | First Team |
| 2013 | JJ Koval | First Team |
| 2013 | Jordan Morris | Third Team |
| 2012 | Adam Jahn | Second Team |
| 2011 | Adam Jahn | Third Team |
| 2010 | Bobby Warshaw | Second Team |
| 2009 | Bobby Warshaw | First Team |
| 2009 | Adam Jahn | Third Team |
| 2009 | Michael Strickland | Third Team |
| 2007 | Scott Bolkan | First Team |
| 2007 | Bobby Warshaw | Third Team |
| 2006 | Darren Fernandez | Second Team |
| 2006 | Galen Thompson | Third Team |
| 2003 | Chad Marshall | Second Team |
| 2002 | Todd Dunivant | First Team |
| 2002 | Roger Levesque | First Team |
| 2002 | Taylor Graham | Third Team |
| 2000 | Lee Morrison | First Team |
| 2000 | Ryan Nelsen | First Team |
| 2000 | Scott Leber | Second Team |
| 2000 | Adam Zapala | Second Team |
| 1999 | Adam Zapala | First Team |
| 1999 | Ryan Nelsen | First Team |
| 1999 | Lee Morrison | Second Team |
| 1998 | Jamie Clark | First Team |
| 1998 | Simon Elliott | First Team |
| 1998 | Shan Gaw | First Team |
| 1998 | Adam Zapala | Second Team |
| 1997 | Jamie Clark | First Team |
| 1997 | Simon Elliott | Second Team |
| 1997 | Shan Gaw | Second Team |
| 1997 | Adam Zapala | Second Team |
| 1996 | Jamie Clark | First Team |
| 1996 | Dan Wytock | First Team |
| 1993 | Ryan Collins | -- |
| 1992 | Ryan Collins | -- |
| 1988 | Mark Semioli | First Team |
| 1987 | Mark Semioli | Third Team |
| 1983 | Giancarlo Ferruzzi | Second Team |
| 1982 | Jorge Titinger | First Team |
| 1981 | Jorge Titinger | First Team |
| 1979 | Dan McNevin | First Team |
| 1978 | Dan McNevin | First Team |
| 1975 | Bruce Mosbacher | Second Team |
| 1974 | Bruce Mosbacher | Second Team |
| 1973 | Mac Taylor | -- |