| Baseball | Owen Cobb | Second Team |
| Carter Graham | Second Team |
| Eddie Park | Third Team |
| Men's Basketball | Brandon Angel | Third Team |
| Michael Jones | Third Team |
| Women's Basketball | Hannah Jump | Second Team |
| Cross Country/Track & Field | Zofia Dudek | First Team |
| Maya Valmon | First Team |
| Ky Robinson | First Team |
| Max McKhann | First Team |
| Kevin Yang | First Team |
| Udodi Onwuzurike | Second Team |
| Field Hockey | Isabelle Pilson | First Team |
| Football | Patrick Fields | First Team |
| Spencer Jorgensen | First Team |
| Walter Rouse | First Team |
| Kendall Williamson | First Team |
| Women's Golf | Brooke Seay | First Team |
| Rose Zhang | First Team |
| Men's Gymnastics | Brandon Briones | First Team |
| Riley Loos | Second Team |
| Ian Gunther | Third Team |
| Women's Lacrosse | Kara Rahaim | First Team |
| Men's Soccer | Carlo Agostinelli | Third Team |
| Keegan Tingey | Third Team |
| Women's Soccer | Abby Greubel | Second Team |
| Softball | Emily Young | Second Team |
| Men's Swimming & Diving | Leon MacAlister | First Team |
| Ron Polonsky | First Team |
| Preston Forst | First Team |
| Luke Maurer | Second Team |
| Women's Swimming & Diving | Allie Raab | First Team |
| Morgan Tankersley | First Team |
| Taylor Ruck | Second Team |
| Men's Tennis | Arthur Fery | Third Team |
| Women's Tennis | Valencia Xu | Second Team |
| Women's Volleyball | Caitie Baird | First Team |
| Elena Oglivie | Third Team |
| Women's Water Polo | Aria Fischer | At-Large Team Member of the Year, First Team |
| Wrestling | Shane Griffith | Second Team |
